Post-Publication Discussion

Jurnal Dakwatul Islam

Jurnal Dakwatul Islam provides opportunities for post-publication discussion as part of its commitment to improving the quality of scholarly publications, encouraging the exchange of ideas, and strengthening integrity and transparency in the development of scientific knowledge.

Post-publication discussion refers to comments, critiques, clarifications, or scholarly feedback concerning articles that have already been published in Jurnal Dakwatul Islam. This process aims to enrich academic understanding, critically examine research arguments and findings, and encourage the development of concepts and theories in the fields of Islamic da'wah, socio-cultural studies, human resource development, economic resource development, and environmental resource development.

1. Scope of Discussion

Post-publication discussions may include the following:

Scholarly Comments: Responses or comments concerning the arguments, methods, results, and conclusions of published articles.
Academic Criticism: Critical analyses presented objectively and supported by scientific evidence and relevant references.
Research Clarification: Requests for clarification from authors regarding research methods, data, interpretation of findings, or other aspects related to a published article.
Development of Ideas: Proposals for new perspectives, approaches, or findings that may broaden academic discussions and contribute to the advancement of knowledge within the journal's focus and scope.
Scientific Corrections: Reports of possible errors, inaccuracies, or issues in published articles that require further examination by the editorial team.

2. Requirements for Submitting Discussions

Readers, researchers, academics, and members of the scholarly community may submit comments on articles published in Jurnal Dakwatul Islam, subject to the following requirements:

Comments must be directly related to articles published in Jurnal Dakwatul Islam.
Submissions must be scholarly, objective, constructive, and supported by logical arguments and relevant references where appropriate.
Comments must use respectful language and demonstrate consideration for the authors and other parties involved in the discussion.
Submissions must not contain plagiarism, defamation, hate speech, personal attacks, or claims that lack adequate supporting evidence.
The identities of the authors submitting comments and any potential conflicts of interest must be disclosed in accordance with the journal's policies.
All submissions must comply with the format and submission procedures established by the editorial team of Jurnal Dakwatul Islam.

3. Evaluation and Publication Process

All submitted comments will be reviewed by the editorial team to assess their relevance, quality of argumentation, compliance with academic ethics, and consistency with the journal's policies. Where necessary, submissions may undergo evaluation by independent reviewers.

The editorial team reserves the right to accept, request revisions to, or reject submissions that do not meet the journal's academic and ethical standards. Approved submissions may be published as discussion articles, scholarly commentaries, or other forms of academic communication, in accordance with the journal's editorial policies.

4. Authors' Right of Reply

Authors whose published articles are the subject of discussion will be given the opportunity to respond to comments or provide clarification. Such responses must be professional, supported by scholarly evidence, and submitted in accordance with the journal's editorial procedures.

Where appropriate and subject to editorial approval, authors' responses may be published alongside the corresponding comments or as separate publications linked to the original discussion.

5. Corrections and Publication Integrity

If post-publication discussions reveal potential substantive errors, suspected ethical misconduct, or other issues that may affect the reliability of a published article, the editorial team will conduct further investigations in an objective and proportionate manner.

Depending on the findings, the journal may take appropriate action, including issuing a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction, where warranted and in accordance with applicable policies and procedures.

6. Journal Commitment

Jurnal Dakwatul Islam is committed to promoting open, responsible, and constructive post-publication discussions to support the advancement of knowledge and improve the quality of scholarly publications. All discussions will be conducted in accordance with the principles of honesty, objectivity, transparency, fairness, and respect for academic ethics.

Through this policy, Jurnal Dakwatul Islam aims to strengthen a culture of scholarly dialogue and make a sustained contribution to the development of Islamic da'wah and community empowerment in the areas of socio-cultural studies, human resources, economic resources, and environmental resources.